| Hope and persistence |
| As I contemplated all that has happened in the last week- EPA ruling, CDC’s challenges for vaccine dissemination, Miranda rights removed, and abortion made illegal, I was grateful for those that do the work sharing how to find hope and resolve to keep at it. See below from Cynthia Tabor from Cities for People followed by links of articles from my Portside Feed on how to interpret what is happening and how to support change. Hope is not just a question of grit or courage. It’s an ontological dimension of our human condition. -Paulo Freire In light of the recent Supreme Court decisions on concealed weapons, Miranda warnings and abortion, I’ve been thinking about the demoralizing impact these trials and disappointments have on those of us involved in the struggle. Sure, these rulings can serve as a moral reminder that there’s still work left to do…but at times this work can seem insurmountable. How we can persist and find hope to enact sustainable social change? Seeking solace and guidance, I revisited an interview I conducted with Ruth Sidel as part of the Welfare Rights Initiative Oral History Project. Her story is nothing short of inspiring: she was a sociology professor at Hunter College who co-founded the Center for the Study of Family Policy in the 1980s, which in turn led to the creation of the grassroots activist group Welfare Rights Initiative. During her lifetime, Ruth was committed to breaking apart misrepresentations of poor women and children, predicated on evident economic disadvantage and social stigmas, both in her writing as well as her teaching. At one point, she provided an example of how the path towards challenging oppression in this country has never been easy: “I think every bit helps and one has to do what one can do. But I think it’s very tough. And, I think it’s a long, long haul…I tell the students about the struggle against child labor….It took 100 years from the first efforts to limit child labor until the Fair Labor Standards Act was passed in 1938, I think it was. A century for that to get passed… We have to use every method we have whether it be writing, speaking, organizing, whatever and know that it will take us, the people after us, and the people before us to do it.” Witnessing these reversals and surviving them gives us the depth necessary to persist. Ruth reminds us that knowing what it’s like to be down and building ourselves back up is our path out of despair and inaction. Child labor was defeated in the United States thanks to this tenacity. Despite the obstacles we face, these flickers of hope allow us to tap into our persistence to continue the good fight. Perhaps this is what Freire meant about hope in dire situations not being based only on our reserves of strength. Hope is tied to our very existence as human beings, and much harder to extinguish. ![]() Abrazos, Cynthia Sources Freire, P. (2000). Pedagogy of freedom: Ethics, democracy, and civic courage. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. Tobar, C. (2012). “Interview with Ruth Sidel,” in Welfare Rights Initiative Oral History Project, http://wri-voices.org/interview/ruth-sidel-interview Sources on recent rulings- compiled by Katayoun 1. Yohe, G. July 2,2022. Supreme Court EPA Climate Ruling: What didCongress Intend with the Clean Air Act? Link 2. Pinker and Silvergate. July 1, 2022. Science and Civil Liberties:The Lost ACLU Lecture of Carl Sagan. Quillette. Link 3. Kanu, H. July 5, 2022. U.S. Supreme Court’s ‘Miranda’ Decision Guts 150-Year-Old Civil Rights Law. Portside/ Reuters. Link |

